Giving critical feedback to someone who gets defensive
A report shuts down or argues every time you raise a performance concern.
Strategy
Name the pattern once, hand them the data, then make the conversation about the fix instead of the fault. Defensiveness drops when the person can see a path out.
I have something on the client decks and I would rather say it straight than circle it. On the last three client calls the deck went out after the meeting had already started. Redfield mentioned it twice on Tuesday. I do not need the history right now. I need to know what changes so it does not happen again on Thursday.
What usually happens next
Most likely: an immediate explanation of why each instance was somebody else's fault.
If they push back
If they argue the facts: "You may be right about the cause. Let us put that aside and agree on the outcome I need, then we can work backward on what got in the way."
What not to say
- You always do this
- People have been complaining about you
- I hate having to have this conversation
- No offense, but
Follow-up
That was a straight conversation and I appreciate you staying in it. You own the deck landing 24 hours ahead of Thursday. I will check in Wednesday morning — and if it is at risk, I want to hear that on Tuesday, not Thursday.
Need this script tailored to a sensitive situation?
No two workplace conflicts are exactly alike. If you are preparing for a highly sensitive, high-stakes meeting and cannot afford to make a mistake, let our executive team write a custom, turn-key script tailored precisely to your situation.
- 24-Hour Delivery
- 100% Confidential
- Step-by-Step Delivery Coaching Notes
Secure checkout, no account needed. You'll answer four short questions right after payment.